Lexington Avenue & 57th Street

23 Feb

Okay, so it’s the “little house” on the corner that really gets me here (sure, it’s not a house and at 6 stories it’s not really little, but you know).  As I’ve said many a time, seeking out the juxtaposition of old and new is one of the endless joys of living in this city – and perhaps one of the unique joys that New York especially provides.  I guess it’s one of the positives of living in the real estate capital of the world (it is the real estate capital of the world, right?), which by its very nature means shits not too regulated (don’t ask a Republican though).  New stuff goes up, old stuff goes down, and sometimes they’re standing right next to each other.  It’s fun to look at.  Would New York be more exciting if no new buildings had gone up since the 1890s?  Probably not, though sure, it might be ultimately prettier.

But what you get instead is the little house on the corner – a small joy to be sure, but a joy none the less.  It’s an older building completely surrounded by a much taller and still old but not as old building.  Forgive me if I don’t know what the kids are into these days but I mean, that’s pretty cool!  As with so many anomalies like this one the question raised is why did this lot survive?  The answer, by the way, is pretty much always that somebody didn’t want to sell.  But why didn’t they want to sell?  Didn’t they know that home is just a fungible asset?  You know, that there’s no heaven, principles are thin straw with which to make a bed, and you’ve got to take everything that you can get in this one world?  I guess not everybody used to know that.  Or I don’t know, maybe they were rich already and they didn’t care.


The little building goes back to around 1875, though it wasn’t 6 stories at the time, and in fact according to some sources it was originally a carriage house, presumably serving one of the townhouses that then made up most of 57th Street (a few of which still survive just down the street).  The larger building went up in the early 1920s as the Allerton Hotel for Women (finished in 1923), a residential hotel specializing, as the name implies, in providing housing for the “professional” class of women.  Since the hotel hadn’t been able to purchase the corner lot before construction they simply planned to build around it.  About midway through construction it seems they did gain possession of the property, through a 21 year lease that gave them the right to tear down the building and erect something new, with the stipulation however that whatever went up had to include its own entrance, stairs and heating system.  I guess they decided it made sense financially to just keep the small building instead, though it was remodeled, with the top 2 floors added.   Slightly less explicable is the fact that they didn’t line up the floors of the remodeled building with the hotel.  Maybe they didn’t expect to keep it long – apparently the corner building remained separately owned until 1960.  As recently as 10 years ago it was still only connected to the hotel on the first and second floors.

The “they” who didn’t line up the floors by the way was architect Arthur Loomis Harmon, whose most famous building to his (partial) credit is probably the Empire State Building – designed by the firm of Shreve, Lamb and Harmon and completed in an amazing 15 months (the 17 story Allerton Hotel – less than 1/5 of the size – seemingly took longer).  Harmon also designed 740 Park Avenue, which today houses one of the highest, if not the highest, concentration of billionaires in the United States.  I probably wouldn’t want to live there.  I probably wouldn’t really want to live in the little house on the corner either, but I would want to spend a night at least.  Right on that 6th floor corner that juts out over the busy busy intersection like a ship’s prow.  It gets to something that always kind of blows my mind about space: I guess namely the fact that it can vary so much in use and hence in value.  An apartment in a building in a certain spot (like 740 Park Ave. say) can be “worth” an astronomical amount; an apartment less than a mile up the road can be worth very little.  Okay fine, we all get that I guess but it’s still wild to think that a wall can demarcate a space – making it private instead of public – and everything that goes with that.  Anyone can stand on the corner of 57th and Lexington Ave; not too many people can be on the 6th floor by the corner windows, in their pajamas, watching TV.


3 Responses to “Lexington Avenue & 57th Street”

  1. George Cauldwell November 14, 2014 at 7:45 pm #

    Chris, your February & March are my Nostalgia Central;

    You seem to appreciate odd connections (and btw, I was up on that 6th floor 57th & Lex many times) …

    there is one (an odd connection) between 134E60, and 698 Lex, the two surrounded brownstones you featured.

    My parents had a stamp business at 134E60 (while living at 166E61), initially called J & A Stamp Company, then renamed Philatelic Center. They sublet the space for several years from a shoe store around the corner from at least 1965, until they moved to more spacious quarters at 692Lex for year or two. When they decided to open a stamp auction house in the 70’s (Philatelic Center, Inc.), they rented that brownstone on the corner of 57th and Lex, sans the ground floor, which housed a boutique. The hotel for women was called The Barbizon. Our stamp auctions were held at a Drake Hotel conference room.

    I have some pics of all of the above.

    • Corner By Corner November 17, 2014 at 3:40 am #

      That’s amazing! How wild to think that you have a connection to both these places (and yes odd connections is exactly the kind of thing I’m always looking for).
      Thanks for sharing this and thanks for following my blog.
      If you have these pictures in digital format I’d love to see them.


  1. Lexington Avenue & 60th Street | corner by corner - March 13, 2014

    […] the house wasn’t designed to blend in quite as easily as it does today.  So yeah, if I was excited by the 6 story building surrounded by (what’s now) the Renaissance Hotel on 57th Street, […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: